At the apartment, Cole and Starr were pleased that Marty had agreed to babysit Hope, and the two decided to spend a romantic night alone. Cole pointed out that Starr had failed to notice a letter that was included in the pamphlet that she had received from Llanview University. The letter requested that Starr contact the university and arrange for an interview. With a renewed sense of hope that she might be accepted at LU, Starr and Cole discussed the benefits of attending the same college.

While Starr and Cole shared a romantic moment, Hannah arrived and insisted that she and Cole had scheduled a study date for that time. After realizing that she had arrived a day early, Hannah apologized and insisted on leaving, but Starr announced that she would pick up Hope, and suggested that Cole and Hannah study at the apartment.

When Marty entered the Buenos Dias Café with Hope, a waitress assumed that Marty was the child's mother. Upon learning that Marty was Hope's grandmother, the waitress insisted that Marty looked young enough to be the child's mother. Afterward, Marty stared at Hope and remarked, "Hope? Do you think grandma can pull this off?"

Marty appeared nervous when Roxy approached the table and inquired about Marty's pregnancy. Although Marty didn't wish to discuss her pregnancy, Roxy persisted. Relating that Mitch would've made a terrible father, Roxy reminded Marty that John was a decent man and would be a wonderful father to her baby. When Roxy mentioned that Natalie wouldn't cause Marty and John any further problems, Marty demanded to know what Roxy had told to Natalie. After explaining that she hadn't revealed Marty's secret to Natalie, Roxy warned, "Take my advice! Don't lie about your kids! Tell John before it's too late!"

Later, Starr arrived at the café and thanked Marty for babysitting Hope. When Marty questioned Starr about the difficulties of raising a toddler, Starr admitted that the job was challenging. Smiling at Hope, Starr declared, "But it's all worth it! You, me, and Daddy are a team!"

Once Starr had left, Cole noticed that Hannah was troubled. In tears, Hannah told Cole that she was experiencing a difficult time getting over her recent breakup. Hannah explained that she had recently ended a relationship with a teacher assistant, who had pursued her, and then dumped her after she had sex with him. Hannah stated that her ex-lover had lost interest in her after she gave in to his advances. Cole listened as a distraught Hannah recalled the night that she had heard her ex making love to another girl inside his classroom.

Hannah apologized for breaking down in front of him, but Cole told her that she didn't owe him an apology. Cole told Hannah that she was a beautiful person and would eventually find someone who deserved her. As she turned to leave, Hannah thanked Cole for listening to her problems and stated that she had never had a friend to confide in. Giving Hannah an innocent hug, Cole stated, "You do now!" At that moment, Starr stood unnoticed in the hall and watched the embrace. Once Hannah walked away, Starr entered the apartment with Hope. As Cole welcomed his daughter home, a suspicious Starr asked if everything was okay. With a slight grin, Cole remarked, "Everything is perfect!"

At the maximum-security prison, Mitch smiled when he observed Allison, who was impersonating Roxy, approach his cell. Mitch asked if Allison had done his bidding, and she happily informed him that he would be pleased with the job she had performed for him. Displaying a cell phone, Allison told him that she had taken pictures of his children.

Although he was discouraged to learn that Jessica still had no memory of him, Mitch was pleased to view pictures of Jessica, Bree, and Shane. However, Mitch expressed displeasure with Allison when she presented him with a picture of Sierra Rose. Referring to the infant as a brat, Mitch demanded to know why Allison had photographed the child. Allison told Mitch that Sierra was a very special child. In a serious tone, Allison stated, "This little girl is your ticket out of here!" Mitch curiosity was piqued.

Inside his office at the police station, John phoned the maximum-security prison and learned that Roxanne Balsom had paid two visits to Mitch Laurence.

When Cristian arrived at the police station for a visit, Layla asked if Jessica had attended Cristian's class. Upon learning that Jessica had made an appearance at the school, Layla maintained that Jessica was stalking Cristian. Insisting that Jessica had the mentality of a high school student, Cristian stated that Jessica had an innocent crush and assured Layla that she had nothing to worry about. Layla admitted that Jessica's sudden presence in Cristian's life intimidated her, but he managed to ease her nerves when he stated that he was annoyed by Jessica's behavior. After making a date for the evening, Cristian gave Layla a kiss and said goodbye.

John was stunned when Natalie entered his office and announced, "I want to congratulate you on the baby!" Suddenly, Natalie realized that John had no idea that Marty was pregnant and attempted to retract her statement, but John demanded answers. At a loss for words, Natalie advised John to speak with Marty.

When John continued to pressure Natalie to tell him the truth, she finally revealed that Marty was with child. As Natalie explained how she had accidentally discovered Marty's pregnancy test, John remembered how strangely Marty had been behaving. With a look of regret, Natalie stated, "We can't continue to take any more trips down memory lane because you're going to be a father. This is going to definitely change things for the two of us!" John watched silently as Natalie exited the room.

Later, Marty stepped inside the office and offered to treat John to dinner. Her face dropped when John replied, "Why, so you can tell me that you're pregnant?"

Brody approached Jessica outside of Llanfair. After noticing that she was wearing a Llanview High School jacket, Brody was stunned when Jessica proudly announced, "I'm a senior there now!" Annoyed by Brody's presence, Jessica rudely asked Brody to stay away from her. Promising to give her some space, Brody handed her a box of her belongings.

Jessica grew frustrated when she realized that she had no memory of the significance of each object. Brody admitted that he had hoped that the articles would remind Jessica of their life together. Jessica wondered if Brody had returned her things because he had decided to let her go. Declaring that he wouldn't give up on her, Brody promised that he wouldn't pressure her any longer. Touched by Brody's words, Jessica told him that he was a nice guy and didn't want to hurt him. With great sadness, Brody wished Jessica luck and walked away. Staring intently at the articles in the box, Jessica suddenly had an idea.

After encountering Brody at the police station, Layla remarked, "Your girlfriend is stalking my boyfriend!" Once Layla explained that Jessica had become obsessed with Cristian, Brody admitted that he wished there was a way to keep Jessica and Cristian apart. Layla told Brody that she had an idea to accomplish that goal.

Jessica approached Cristian at the café and presented him with a large box. When Cristian inquired about what was inside, Jessica exclaimed, "It's everything that you've ever given me! Since we're broken up, I don't need it anymore!" As Jessica walked off, Cristian slowly opened the box. Cristian smiled as he studied each item and recalled memories from the past. Meanwhile, Jessica smiled as she observed Cristian through the window.

Inside Llanfair, Viki told Charlie that she had asked Téa to draw up divorce papers. When Charlie asked if Viki was certain that she wanted to proceed with the divorce, Viki informed him that she was leaving town and had asked Téa to put the divorce on hold until she returned. Viki gave Charlie a detailed account of her encounter with Dorian. Charlie was surprised to learn that Dorian had begged Viki to forgive him. Admitting that Dorian could be very convincing, Viki told Charlie that she didn't want to give him any false hope regarding their future.

Relating that Jessica was stuck in the past, Viki feared that Bree might be affected by Jessica's behavior, and believed that it was best to leave town with the child for a while. While Viki prayed that Jessica would eventually regain her memory and realize the woman that she once was, Charlie hoped that Viki would find it in her heart to forgive him. Stating that she had plans to stay with Kevin in London for a few weeks, Viki informed Charlie that she had to concentrate on Bree. Charlie had faith that he and Viki would find their way back to one another, but Viki refused to make any promises.

Recalling how Viki had left town before, Charlie reminded her that they had managed to reunite. Vowing to never give up on her, Charlie gave Viki a passionate kiss. As Charlie attempted to stir up emotions in Viki, Natalie entered the room and interrupted the moment. Afterward, Viki pulled away, and Charlie said goodbye. Observing her mother's emotional state, Natalie asked if Viki was all right. In tears, Viki blurted out, "No! It's hard to say goodbye to somebody you love so much!" Consoling her mother, Natalie agreed.

When Gigi and Rex arrived at the cottage, Shane inquired about Sierra. Gigi explained that they would have to wait awhile before Sierra could reside at the cottage. Rex was suspicious when Shane mentioned that a nurse had taken a photo of him and Sierra at the hospital. Once Shane had left the room, Rex tried to cheer Gigi up, but she was heartbroken over losing Sierra. As they discussed the upcoming custody hearing, Gigi told Rex that he didn't need to get involved, but Rex promised to bring Sierra home to Shane. Afterward, Rex left to uncover information regarding the mysterious nurse.

Later, Shane questioned whether his mother and father were going to reunite. Admitting that things were calmer, Gigi told Shane that she and Rex were no longer romantically involved.

At the apartment, Schuyler told Rachel that Gigi intended to fight for custody of Sierra, and that he had nearly lost the opportunity to bring Sierra home from the hospital. Schuyler related that Gigi had declined his offer to share custody of the child. As Schuyler and Rachel tended to baby Sierra, Rex showed up at the apartment and asked for a moment alone with Schuyler. Lashing out at Schuyler, Rex criticized him for not allowing Gigi to raise Sierra. Schuyler insisted that he loved his daughter, but Rex reminded him that Gigi had risked her life to protect the child, and deserved to raise her.

Gigi and Shane were pleased when Roxy arrived at the cottage. Gigi apologized for falling for Schuyler, and Roxy embraced her. After the two women had made amends, Roxy hugged Shane, but was suddenly overcome with emotion. Holding onto Shane for dear life, Roxy mumbled, "All this talk about babies has got me all shook up!"

Roxy listened as Gigi explained that she and Rex intended to fight for custody of Sierra. As Gigi discussed the horror of having Sierra removed from her arms at the hospital, Roxy had a disturbing flashback from the past. Many years before, Allison Perkins had snatched a baby from the arms of a young Roxy and ordered her to keep her mouth shut. A look of horror crossed Roxy's face as she remembered that moment from the past.